California has a diverse population, and its laws aim to ensure equal treatment for all individuals regardless of race, ethnicity, or identity. Penal Code 13519.4 PC expressly prohibits racial and identity profiling by law enforcement officers.
Empower yourself by understanding the provisions of this law and how it relates to DUI arrests. This knowledge can be essential for individuals who believe they have been victims of profiling, giving them the power to defend their rights.
Know that racial profiling is not only against the law in California but also violates the United States Constitution. PC 13519.4 explicitly prohibits racial profiling, providing a secure legal framework. The code section states that a law enforcement officer shall not engage in racial profiling, giving you reassurance in your rights.
PC 13519 says, "(a) The commission shall develop and disseminate guidelines and training for all peace officers in California as described in subdivision (a) of Section 13510 and who adhere to the standards approved by the commission, on the racial and cultural differences among the residents of this state.
The course or courses of instruction and the guidelines shall stress understanding and respect for racial, identity, and cultural differences and the development of effective, noncombative methods of carrying out law enforcement duties in a diverse racial, identity, and cultural environment.
The Legislature finds and declares that (1) Racial profiling is a practice that presents a great danger to the fundamental principles of a democratic society. It is abhorrent and cannot be tolerated. (2) Motorists who the police have stopped for no reason other than the color of their skin or their apparent nationality or ethnicity are the victims of discriminatory practices. (3) The legislature intends that more than additional training is required to address the pernicious practice of racial profiling and that enactment of this bill is in no way dispositive of the issue of how the state should deal with racial profiling."
If there is evidence that a law enforcement officer profiled you illegally, leading to your DUI charges, an experienced California criminal defense attorney can potentially leverage this to get your charges reduced or dropped. A defense attorney can review the circumstances of your arrest, gather evidence, and represent you in court, ensuring your rights are protected throughout the legal process.
What Constitutes Racial and Identity Profiling?
According to PC 13519.4, racial and identity profiling are defined as "the consideration of, or reliance on, to any degree, actual or perceived race, color, ethnicity, national origin, age, religion, gender identity or expression, sexual orientation, or mental or physical disability in deciding which persons to subject to a stop or in deciding upon the scope or substance of law enforcement activities following a stop."
In simpler terms, this means that a law enforcement officer cannot use an individual's appearance, identity, or other identifiable characteristic, such as race or gender, as the sole basis for initiating a stop or taking further action.
Profiling occurs when an officer's decision to stop or take further action is influenced primarily by one of these characteristics rather than by the individual's conduct or information related to suspected criminal activity.
The only exception to this policy is that an officer may consider these characteristics only to the extent that they are included in a suspect's description.
For example, if a suspect description contains information that they are a practicing Sikh wearing a turban, officers may make the stop based on this information. They may not, however, stop someone simply for wearing a Sikh turban. "Culturally diverse" and "cultural diversity" include, but are not limited to, disability, gender, nationality, religion, and sexual orientation issues.
Racial and Identity Profiling in the Context of DUI Arrests
Racial and identity profiling can be particularly concerning in the context of DUI arrests. DUI stops occur at an officer's discretion when deciding whether a vehicle or driver appears suspicious or is driving erratically.
Unfortunately, this discretionary power can sometimes lead to unlawful profiling practices where individuals are targeted based on race or other identity factors rather than actual evidence of intoxicated driving. Some common scenarios that may suggest racial or identity profiling in DUI stops include:
- Pretextual Stops: When an officer uses a minor traffic violation, such as a broken taillight or failing to signal, as a pretext to stop a driver primarily because of their race, ethnicity, or identity.
- Unjustified Field Sobriety Tests: Conducting field sobriety tests or breathalyzer tests on drivers based on their appearance rather than on any observable signs of intoxication.
- Disparate Treatment: Treating drivers differently during DUI stops based on their race or identity, such as detaining some individuals longer or being more likely to arrest them despite similar behavior to that of others not arrested.
What Are the Legal Implications of Racial Profiling in DUI Cases?
Racial profiling not only violates an individual's civil rights but can also have significant legal implications in DUI cases. Suppose a DUI arrest is the result of unlawful racial profiling. In that case, the evidence obtained during the stop may be considered inadmissible in court, potentially leading to a reduction or dismissal of charges.
This means that if you were unfairly targeted due to your race or identity, the charges against you could be dropped, and you could avoid the serious consequences of a DUI conviction.
This is because the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution protects against unreasonable searches and seizures. If an officer lacks reasonable suspicion or probable cause to stop a driver, any evidence gathered during that traffic stop, including field sobriety test results or breathalyzer readings, could be suppressed. Specific examples include:
- Violation of Rights: Racial profiling violates an individual's constitutional rights, particularly the right to equal protection under the law. This breach can be a critical point in challenging the legality of the stop and subsequent charges.
- Evidentiary Concerns: If a stop was initiated without reasonable suspicion or probable cause due to profiling, any evidence obtained, such as breathalyzer results or field sobriety tests, may be deemed inadmissible in court. This can lead to a reduction or dismissal of charges.
What are the Defenses Against DUI Charges Involving Racial Profiling?
If you believe you have been racially profiled and subsequently charged with a DUI, a knowledgeable and experienced criminal defense lawyer can employ several strategies to defend your rights and combat the charges effectively. These include:
- Thorough Investigation of the Stop and Arrest: Reviewing all aspects of the DUI stop and arrest, including body camera footage, dashcam recordings, and police reports, to identify any evidence of racial profiling or procedural errors.
- Motions to Suppress Evidence: If there is evidence of racial profiling, your attorney can file a motion to suppress the evidence obtained from the unlawful stop. If the court approves this motion, the prosecution may lack enough evidence to continue with the DUI charges, possibly leading to a dismissal.
- Challenging the Credibility of the Arresting Officer: If racial profiling is suspected, your attorney may question the arresting officer's credibility, especially if there are complaints about biased policing practices. This can weaken the prosecution's case and lead to better outcomes for the defendant.
For more information, contact our criminal defense law firm, Eisner Gorin LLP, based in Los Angeles, CA.
Related Content:
If you have one phone call from jail, call us! If you are facing criminal charges,