What is a Felony Settlement Conference in California?
Suppose you've been charged with a felony in California. In that case, there's a high likelihood that the judge will mandate that you attend a Felony Settlement Conference (FSC) before moving ahead with a trial.
This is a crucial phase where your case may be resolved before going to trial, often offering a chance for a more favorable outcome. Having a skilled criminal defense attorney representing your interests can make a huge difference in the outcome of your case at this early stage.
A felony settlement conference is a meeting your attorney and the district attorney exchange information, discuss resolving the case, and inform the judge if the case is ready for trial.
The primary goal is to help the parties negotiate a resolution to the case. After the arraignment, an FSC is set. Simply put, lawyers and the deputy district attorney will attempt to negotiate a case disposition.
If they are unable to resolve the case, a preliminary hearing date is set. A settlement conference, which can be voluntary or court-ordered, is often held close to the court date.
To prepare for a FSC, each side must prepare a written settlement conference brief, file it, and serve it to the other party ten days before the hearing.
In a settlement conference, a judge or volunteer attorney assists the parties by evaluating the case's strengths and weaknesses and attempting to negotiate a settlement of the dispute, but without making any decisions or orders in the case.
Many criminal courts feature a process for early disposition of felony cases. The terminology surrounding this process differs from courthouse to courthouse, but it is sometimes called the early disposition court.
What is a Felony Settlement Conference?
A Felony Settlement Conference (FSC) is a meeting between the prosecution, the defense (which includes the defendant and their attorney), and sometimes a judge. The goal is to negotiate a resolution to the case (known as a "disposition") without the need for a trial. FSCs typically occur after the arraignment hearing but before a trial begins.
During the FSC, both parties discuss the case's strengths and weaknesses, potential evidence, and legal strategies.
This provides an opportunity to reach a mutually agreeable settlement, such as reducing charges, dismissing some charges, or negotiating a plea deal. The FSC allows the parties to explore potential outcomes without the uncertainty, time, and expense of a full trial.
What Happens During an FSC?
An FSC is usually conducted in a closed courtroom or the judge's chambers. The setting is informal compared to a trial but remains structured and serious. During the conference:
- Both the prosecution and defense will exchange information about the case (known as "discovery").
- The prosecutor will present their view of the case, including any evidence they plan to present at trial and the charges they believe the defendant should face.
- The defense attorney will outline any defenses available, highlighting weaknesses in the prosecution's case and emphasizing factors that may mitigate the charges.
- The judge, if involved, may act as a neutral party to facilitate negotiations and provide insight into the potential outcomes based on the evidence presented. The judge may also offer opinions on the appropriateness of plea deals or suggest alternative resolutions. Their role is crucial in maintaining the fairness and integrity of the process.
What are the Potential Benefits of an FSC?
The primary objective of an FSC is to explore a settlement that avoids the need for a trial. Trials are costly, time-consuming, and unpredictable, so both parties generally have an interest in resolving the case efficiently. The benefits of an FSC include:
- Resolution of the Case: Ideally, the FSC results in a plea agreement that resolves the case. This may involve the defendant pleading guilty or no contest to lesser charges, avoiding more serious penalties if the case were to go to trial. This successful resolution can bring a sense of relief and hope for a better future.
- Reduction of Charges: A successful FSC may lead to the prosecutor agreeing to reduce felony charges to misdemeanors or dismissing some charges altogether, significantly lessening the potential penalties.
- Avoiding Uncertainty of a Trial: Trials can be unpredictable. Even a strong defense does not guarantee a favorable outcome. The FSC offers a way to control the result, reducing the risk of harsher sentences if the case proceeds to trial. This control can empower you in the legal process.
How Often does an FSC resolve Felony Cases?
While not every case will be settled at an FSC, a significant majority of felony cases are resolved through FSC dispositions rather than going to trial.
In fact, according to the Judicial Council of California, only 2 percent of felony cases actually make it to trial-meaning most are resolved before the trial stage, often through an FSC. This high success rate should instill confidence in the FSC process.
In California, the high costs of trials, both in terms of financial expense and court resources, make settlement conferences a critical aspect of the criminal justice system.
While each case is unique, and outcomes depend on factors like the strength of the evidence and the parties' willingness to negotiate, the FSC is often the setting where both parties are most incentivized to resolve.
Why You Need an Experienced Criminal Defense Attorney
Considering that your case will likely be resolved in a Felony Settlement Conference, your best hope of a favorable outcome is to have an experienced California criminal defense attorney in your corner. Here's why:
- Skilled Negotiation: A defense attorney's key role during an FSC is to negotiate with the prosecution on your behalf. An experienced attorney knows how to exploit weaknesses in the prosecution's case to advocate for reduced charges or alternative sentencing options. They are your advocate, working tirelessly to secure the best possible outcome for you.
- Strategic Insight: An experienced defense attorney can provide invaluable insight into how the judge or jury might view your case based on their knowledge of the law and their familiarity with local courts. This helps in determining whether a settlement offer is fair or if you should take your chances at trial.
- Comprehensive Guidance: The legal system is complex, especially with felony charges. Without proper legal guidance, you may not fully grasp the long-term consequences of a plea deal, including its impact on your criminal record or future job opportunities. The right attorney will help you understand the ramifications of any potential settlement so you can make informed choices.
- Protecting Your Rights: A good attorney will ensure that any settlement offer is in your best interest and that you are not pressured into accepting an unfair deal. If the prosecution's case is weak, your attorney can push for a dismissal of charges or a highly favorable plea agreement.
For additional information, contact our California criminal defense law firm, Eisner Gorin LLP, based in Los Angeles.
Related Content:
If you have one phone call from jail, call us! If you are facing criminal charges,