Can a Judge Extend Probation After a Violation?

In California, Can a Judge Extend Your Probation if a Violation Occurred?

Probation in California, a viable alternative to incarceration, allows you to serve your sentence under specific conditions while staying in the community. However, it's crucial to grasp that breaching these conditions can lead to severe outcomes, including probation revocation and imprisonment. This situation demands utmost caution and respect for the law, as the potential consequences are significant and can have a profound impact on your life.

Can a Judge Extend Your Probation After a Violation?

A judge has the authority to extend probation if was violated, but it involves a hearing and consideration of various factors.

In California, a judge has the authority to extend your probation if you've violated its terms. This extension is not a simple decision, but a process that involves a hearing and the consideration of various factors. While this may seem like bad news, it is a preferable alternative to having your probation revoked entirely and serving a jail sentence.

However, convincing the judge to extend probation instead of imposing harsher penalties can be challenging. Judges weigh a range of factors, including the nature of the violation, your overall compliance record, and your willingness to address the underlying issues.

Simply put, a judge can extend your probation if a violation occurs. The judge has the authority to revoke, modify, or change the original probation order. If a probation violation is found, the judge may extend the probation, add additional terms, or even revoke it entirely, which could result in imprisonment.

Judge's Discretion

When a violation of probation occurs, the court can hold a hearing to determine the facts. The judge, with significant discretion, decides how to respond to the violation. This underscores the importance of strictly adhering to the terms of your probation, as the judge's decision can have serious implications.

If a violation is found, the judge may choose to extend the length of your probation. They can also add new terms to your probation, such as drug counseling or increased supervision. This underscores the judge's discretion and the potential for a second chance, making it clear that your actions during probation can significantly influence the outcome.

The judge can also revoke your probation, which would mean you would no longer be on probation and may have to serve the original sentence. The judge will consider factors such as the nature of the violation, your prior criminal history, and your compliance with probation terms when determining the consequences. This underscores the weight of the judge's decisions and the importance of your actions during probation.

Legal Standard of Proof

In California, your probation officer, who is responsible for monitoring your compliance with the conditions of your probation, typically alerts the judge in your case of any suspected probation violations. This is typically done at a pre-revocation hearing, where the probation officer testifies in court and presents the judge with a report detailing the violation.

If the judge determines there is probable cause that you violated probation, they will issue a bench warrant for your arrest. If you are already in custody, the judge can issue a detention order to keep you in custody.

At this point, your probation is summarily revoked pending your formal probation violation hearing. During this time, you must continue to abide by your probation terms even though your probationary period has technically paused (tolled).

Once a bench warrant is issued for your arrest, you can be apprehended at any time. To avoid an arrest scene, our criminal defense lawyers would file a motion in court to recall (or quash) your warrant and request a probation revocation hearing date.

When someone is accused of violating probation, the legal standard used in their probation violation hearing differs significantly from that of a criminal trial.

A prosecutor does not need to prove the violation "beyond a reasonable doubt," as is required for a conviction in criminal court. Instead, they only need to establish the violation by a "preponderance of the evidence."

This standard means that the evidence must only show it is more likely than not that the violation occurred. Due to this lighter burden of proof, defending against a probation violation requires meticulous preparation and a well-crafted legal strategy. This underscores the seriousness of the situation and the need for thorough preparation, making you aware of the gravity of the situation and the necessity for careful planning.

Common Probation Violations

Technical violations are when you violate one of the terms of probation. Direct violations are when you commit an entirely new criminal offense. In California, there are many different types of common probation violations, including the following:

Failure to appear for a court date,
Failure to report to the probation officer,
Failure to submit to or pass a drug test,
Failure to complete community service hours,
Failure to attend DUI school,
Failure to attend counseling, such as anger management or a batterer's program in domestic violence cases,
Committing a new crime during the probationary period,
Failure to attend rehab, such as substance abuse treatment,
Failure to seek or maintain employment,
Failure to finish a GED program or earn a high school diploma,
Willful failure to pay fines or restitution.

Notably, missing a fine or restitution payment will not typically initiate a probation revocation as long as the non-payment was due to a change in circumstances or that you were unaware of it when the judge granted probation. Rather, the judge can extend your probation to give you more time to pay.

If you are unable to make a court-ordered payment, contact the court immediately. If you delay, the judge might consider your inaction as willful non-payment, which could lead to an extension of your probation or other penalties. It's essential to recognize that failing to meet financial obligations can have severe consequences during probation.

Probation Violating Hearing

You are entitled to a probation violation hearing (PVH) in California if you allegedly violated the terms of your probation, such as failing a drug test or not completing counseling. PVHs can be difficult to win since prosecutors have to prove your violation only by a preponderance of the evidence.

At your probation revocation hearing in California, prosecutors will present evidence, witnesses, and arguments to convince the judge that you violated one or more of your probationary terms. Understanding this process can help you prepare for your hearing and feel more in control of the situation.

Unlike with California criminal trials, hearsay evidence is generally admissible at probation violation hearings as long as it is reliable. Hearsay is a statement made by someone other than a witness testifying at the trial, and it is offered to prove the truth of the statement's content.

Notably, there are limitations to the admissibility of hearsay evidence. For example, if hearsay is the only evidence of your probation violation, the judge may need to show "good cause" to allow the hearsay instead of live testimony. If the judge cannot show good cause, you would have the Sixth Amendment right to cross-examine the person making the allegation against you.

At that point, we would counter with our evidence, witnesses, and arguments that you did not violate probation. We can also argue that any violations were not your fault or not serious enough to justify having your probation revoked.

If the judge determines that you committed no probation violation, then you will get to remain on probation with the same terms as before. Suppose the judge determines you did violate probation. In that case, the judge then decides whether to give you a second chance by reinstating probation with or without additional or modified terms or revoke your probation, which may include remanding you into custody.

What About Bail?

In California, the judge decides whether you can remain out on bail or your recognizance pending your probation violation hearing. In reality, judges are more likely to let you out of custody if you are on misdemeanor probation rather than felony probation.

In serious cases where the judge believes you pose a public safety or flight risk, they may order a "no-bail hold." With decades of experience defending individuals accused of probation violations, we can often persuade judges to grant bail by demonstrating that you have otherwise been compliant with the terms of your probation.

How a Judge Might Respond

If the court finds that a violation has occurred, the judge has several options in determining how to proceed. Possible responses include:

Reinstating Probation Without Changes: If the violation is minor and you're otherwise compliant, the judge may decide to reinstate your probation as is, allowing you to continue under the same terms.
Extending Probation: A judge may decide to extend your probation period to give you additional time to fulfill the requirements and demonstrate continued compliance.
Modifying the Terms of Probation: The court may impose stricter conditions, such as mandatory counseling, additional community service hours, or increased reporting requirements.
Imposing Jail Time but Reinstituting Probation: For more serious violations, the judge may order a short jail term before reinstating probation under the same or amended terms and conditions.
Revoking Probation Entirely: If the judge feels that continued probation is not appropriate, they may revoke it, resulting in the imposition of a jail or prison sentence based on the original conviction.

The outcome largely depends on the nature of the violation, your history while on probation, and how effectively your attorney presents your case.

How a Defense Attorney Can Help

Given the lower burden of proof in probation violation hearings, as well as the increased likelihood that the judge will be less lenient after a violation, hiring a skilled California criminal defense attorney can make a huge difference in whether you receive leniency. An experienced attorney may employ several strategies to mitigate the consequences of a probation violation, including the following:

Challenging the Alleged Violation: Your lawyer may show evidence that no violation occurred, especially if there's insufficient evidence or if the allegations are based on a misunderstanding.
Presenting Mitigating Circumstances: If the violation did happen, your attorney can present evidence demonstrating that it was minor, unintentional, or the result of circumstances beyond your control. For instance, a medical emergency might justify a missed probation check-in, or you might have been unaware that your behavior constituted a violation. Other mitigating factors may include having no prior offenses or demonstrating that you pose no risk to public safety.
Demonstrating Good Faith Efforts: An attorney can highlight your prior compliance, participation in mandatory programs, and efforts to meet probation terms. This can help convince the judge that you take your probation seriously.
Proposing Alternative Solutions: Your lawyer might negotiate for alternatives to jail, such as increased community service hours, participation in a treatment program, or other constructive measures that allow you to avoid incarceration.
Arguing for Probation Extension Over Jail Time: One of the most compelling arguments your attorney can make is that extending your probation serves the interests of justice while also holding you accountable. This solution enables you to rectify your mistakes without the disruption and potential harm associated with incarceration.

Extension May Be the Best Outcome

When you violate your probation, the judge will typically only consider reinstating the original terms of probation if the violation was minor or incidental. Extending probation can feel like a setback, but it is often the most favorable alternative to jail.

It allows you to remain in the community, maintain employment, and continue working toward fulfilling your obligations. Jail time, on the other hand, can result in job loss, housing instability, and other long-term consequences that make rebuilding your life significantly harder.

Judges often favor resolutions that promote rehabilitation over punishment, as long as the individual demonstrates a commitment to improving their behavior. A skilled defense attorney knows how to frame the argument for an extension in a way that resonates with the court.

For more information, contact our criminal defense law firm, Eisner Gorin LLP, located in Los Angeles, CA.

Related Content:

Extended Probation