The consequences of a false accusation of rape can be catastrophic for the accused, even in cases where the charges are ultimately dropped. A recent news story reminds us of the profound damage such accusations can inflict.
Crystal Mangum, who made headlines in 2006 when she accused three Duke University lacrosse players of raping her, has now publicly admitted that her story was fabricated.
Although the charges against the players David Evans, Collin Finnerty, and Reade Seligmann were eventually dismissed, the harm to their reputations and personal lives was immeasurable.
This case underscores an important reality faced by those falsely accused of rape. Society's justifiably strong stance against sexual violence can result in severe social stigma, even when accusations are unproven or false.
While it's important to note that false accusations are not the norm, research indicates they do occur. In fact, studies suggest that between 2 and 10 percent of rape allegations are false.
The consequences for the individuals involved in these cases extend far beyond legal fees and court appearances. They can face irrevocable damage to their reputations, relationships, careers, and mental health, often leading to emotional distress and trauma.
Few criminal allegations are as devastating to a client as being arrested or investigated for a sexual offense. An arrest for rape can occur without corroborating or forensic evidence or even where reasonable doubt may exist of the alleged victim.
Rape is codified under California Penal Code Section 261. It's generally defined as nonconsensual sexual intercourse by means of force, threats, fraud, or with a victim who is unconscious or incapable of giving consent.
Typically, when people hear the word "rape," they often believe it's having sexual intercourse by means of physical force. However, even if no physical force is used, rape charges may be pursued by the prosecutor where the victim is intoxicated or physically or mentally disabled to provide lawful consent.
The Real-World Impact of False Accusations
False accusations can shatter lives and upend families. Defending against a rape charge can be financially draining, with legal costs escalating into tens of thousands of dollars.
The accused may lose their job, be ostracized by their community, and face long-lasting damage to their personal and professional relationships.
Even a not-guilty verdict or dropped charges might not be enough to restore their reputation. Crystal Mangum's story serves as a poignant reminder of this dynamic. Despite being exonerated, public doubt and condemnation lingered, and the accused Duke lacrosse players endured years of fallout that no legal resolution could erase.
The sigma of a rape accusation can be devastating as family, friends, and co-workers assume the worst about a person. The consequences of a sex crime conviction are life-changing.
You can face rape charges when you engage in sexual intercourse with another person, and certain factors are met. For example, sexual intercourse can be against their will OR without their consent.
This means a rape case can be filed if the act was achieved not only through force or violence but also with duress, menace, fear of bodily harm, fear of retaliation, or fraud.
If you have been accused, arrested, or charged with rape, you need to immediately contact our experienced rape defense attorneys at Eisner Gorin LLP. We might be able to uncover evidence that will disprove or minimize the damage of a rape accusation before the district attorney files formal charges.
Penal Code 148.5 and the Consequences of False Reporting
California law acknowledges the harm caused by false criminal reports, including false accusations of rape. Penal Code 148.5 PC makes it a misdemeanor offense to knowingly file a false report to law enforcement or a grand jury about the commission of a crime, including rape.
If convicted under this statute, the person faces penalties of up to six months in jail and fines. While this law recognizes the seriousness of false accusations, its penalties pale in comparison to those faced by someone accused of rape. This disparity raises questions about equity in accountability.
What are the Penalties for Rape?
A person convicted of rape in California could face significant prison time. For example:
- Rape by force, fear, or threats of violence typically carries a penalty of 3, 6, or 8 years in prison.
- Rape by fraud or deceit - where the victim is misled about the nature of the act - is punishable by up to 8 years in prison.
- Rape involving drugs or alcohol that renders the victim unconscious or incapable of consent can also lead to sentences of 3, 6, or 8 years.
- If the victim is a minor between the ages of 14 and 18, the punishment is increased to 7, 9, or 11 years in state prison.
- If the victim is under 14 years old, the sentence will be 9, 11, or 13 years of incarceration
A rape conviction will also include a requirement to register as a sex offender (possibly for life), count as a "strike" penalty according to California's 'Three Strikes" law, and mandatory DNA submission.
These penalties could increase if you have prior convictions, or if there were multiple victims, etc. If this offense counts as your third "strike," you could even face 25 years to life imprisonment.
How Can a Defense Attorney Help You?
If you are falsely accused of rape in California, your priority is to protect your legal rights and build a robust defense strategy to counter the allegations. The best way to even the odds in these cases is with the help of an experienced California criminal defense attorney.
A knowledgeable attorney will investigate the details of the case thoroughly, scrutinizing the accuser's statements, reviewing evidence, and identifying inconsistencies.
For example, they might uncover text messages, surveillance footage, or witness statements that contradict the accusations. They also work to expose any possible motives for false allegations, such as personal disputes, financial incentives, or attempts to gain custody or leverage in a legal proceeding.
Beyond developing a strong defense, your attorney can help you manage the public relations aspect of your case. False accusations often generate intense scrutiny from the press and social media.
A good attorney will advise you on how to handle this attention and may even work with public relations professionals to protect your reputation as much as possible during the process.
Finally, an attorney can explore whether you have grounds to file a civil lawsuit against the accuser for defamation, emotional distress, or other damages caused by their false allegations.
Although no amount of compensation can undo the harm caused, it may bring some measure of justice. For additional information, contact our criminal defense law firm, Eisner Gorin LLP, based in Los Angeles.
Related Content:
If you have one phone call from jail, call us! If you are facing criminal charges,