Licensed professionals in California play a critical role in protecting public health, safety, and trust. Facing a formal complaint with the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) can be challenging, particularly if the complaint also stems from criminal charges you might be facing.
It's important to understand that not all complaints filed with the DCA are automatically referred to its Division of Investigation (DOI); some of the more minor issues can be resolved directly with your licensing board.
The DCA has developed clear referral guidelines, separating complaints into categories based on the severity of the allegations. Having a basic knowledge of these severity categories can help you know what to expect based on the allegations made against you.
The DCA helps consumers make wise purchasing decisions by informing them about the laws that protect them, explaining what they should know about a business, and letting them know what their responsibilities are to protect themselves.
The DCA refers complaints to the appropriate licensing board or agency. You can file a complaint with the DCA online or by calling (800) 952-5210.
To file a complaint, you must Include as many details and documentary evidence as possible and be specific about what you expect and when you want a solution. Keep a copy of all letters and correspondence.
You need to include the nature of your complaint, the date, time, and location of the incident, and the name, address, and phone number of any witnesses.
Also include bills, statements, canceled checks, insurance reimbursement statements, correspondence, and court documents. After filing a complaint, the board will notify you in writing about the status of your complaint. The board might not be able to investigate if you can't provide authorizations for release of information.
An Overview of the DCA's Complaint Prioritization System
Knowledgeable consumers discourage the activities of unlicensed, negligent, or unethical practitioners and encourage licensees to be more competitive. Numerous DCA booklets, brochures, fact sheets, and consumer guides are distributed to help inform and educate the public and licensees.
The DCA will only license those professionals who pass specialized examinations and meet the experience and education requirements, ensuring that only qualified individuals are legally permitted to provide services.
Licensing also ensures that practitioners perform their duties to a certain standard and provides consumers with a means of recourse if a service is not delivered fairly or competently.
The DCA oversees regulatory boards and bureaus that license various professions. To determine which complaints require DOI involvement, the agency has created a priority system. Complaints are divided into four main categories:
- Category 1 - Urgent - Immediate referral to DOI.
- Category 2 - High - Discuss with DOI prior to assigning to the Board.
- Category 3 - Complaints appropriate to be worked by the Board.
- Category 4 - Complaints appropriate to be worked by the Board.
Complaints range from minor infractions and administrative issues (Category 4) to urgent, high-risk violations (Category 1).
While some matters may be addressed solely by the licensing board, others, particularly in the more severe categories, warrant DOI engagement and may result in both professional and criminal consequences. Being familiar with these categories can help you understand the nature of a referral and prepare a strategic response. Below, we'll explore the specifics of each.
Category 4 - Least Severe Complaints
Category 4 complaints involve administrative or minor issues that typically do not threaten public safety. The licensing board handles these cases directly and does not require DOI intervention. Examples include:
- Failure to display your license number at your place of business.
- Minor recordkeeping violations, such as incomplete files or failure to release a client's records.
- Continuing education violations, such as failing to meet mandated professional development requirements.
- False or misleading advertising that is not criminal or egregious.
While Category 4 violations may seem minor, they can still have serious implications for your reputation and professional standing if not addressed promptly.
Category 3 - Moderate Complaints
Category 3 represents complaints involving minor misconduct or potential harm but is still insufficient to justify immediate DOI referral. These infractions often require board oversight but may involve inspections or other forms of investigation. Examples include:
- Unlicensed practice or working with a delinquent license resulting in minor or potential financial harm.
- General unprofessional conduct or negligence that caused no significant harm.
- Quality-of-work complaints that suggest substandard practices.
- Minor violations of laws related to business operations, such as lacking required permits or insurance.
Licensed professionals may face additional scrutiny, including hearings or mandated corrective actions, for Category 3 complaints.
Category 2 - High Priority Complaints
Category 2 complaints involve more serious actions that result in tangible harm and may require a consultation with the DOI before being referred to them. While many of these complaints fall under civil or administrative enforcement, they may also raise potential legal issues. Examples include:
- Gross negligence or incompetence leading to significant financial loss or injury (under $10,000).
- Criminal conduct, such as examination cheating or other forms of ethical misconduct.
- Unlicensed activity or aiding unlicensed activity that caused measurable harm.
If you are facing a Category 2 allegation, the stakes are higher. These cases may involve civil penalties, board-imposed disciplinary actions, or legal repercussions.
Category 1 - Most Severe Complaints
Category 1 complaints represent urgent and high-risk cases that must be immediately referred to the DOI. These involve allegations of imminent danger to public safety or criminal activity and may lead to both disciplinary action and criminal prosecution. Examples include:
- Practicing under the influence of drugs or alcohol results in serious injury or death.
- Acts of sexual misconduct with a client.
- Financial fraud over $10,000, including elder financial abuse or insurance fraud.
- Aiding and abetting unlicensed practice leads to catastrophic harm or death.
- Examination subversion or attempts to use fraudulent documentation for licensure.
- Violent threats or harm directed at inspectors or employees of a board or bureau.
Category 1 allegations are the most serious and often parallel criminal violations such as felony assault, fraud, or manslaughter. Licensed professionals accused of these offenses must contend with the dual challenges of preserving their careers and defending against criminal charges.
The Intersection of Professional and Criminal Defense
When facing a DCA Category 1 complaint with potential criminal ramifications, you are likely dealing with legal issues on two fronts: the criminal side and the licensing side. In such situations, it's in your best interest to hire a California criminal defense attorney who has experience in both criminal and administrative law.
A good attorney can help you navigate both processes and develop a cohesive defense strategy that helps you defend against criminal charges while also minimizing the negative effects it could have on your professional career. For more information, contact our criminal defense law firm, Eisner Gorin LLP, based in Los Angeles, CA.
Related Content:
If you have one phone call from jail, call us! If you are facing criminal charges,