Whether you're being detained as a witness or as a suspect in a crime, being questioned by the police in California can be intimidating at best and damaging to your case at worst. A police interrogation is designed to elicit information that could be used as evidence in a criminal prosecution.
Without a proper understanding of your rights, you risk saying something that could incriminate you or impact your legal position. To protect yourself, it's critical to know what to do and what to avoid during such situations.
The criminal justice system can be intimidating for those unfamiliar with laws, procedures, and policies. Many suspects facing criminal charges make the crucial mistake of assuming that if they didn't commit the crime, they have nothing to worry about.
However, without a proper understanding of your rights, you risk saying something that could incriminate you or impact your legal position. This lack of knowledge can lead to serious consequences, as county jails and state prisons hold many innocent people.
Speaking with a police officer can be intimidating, so it's important to handle these encounters strategically. Often, officers might try to keep things casual and talk to you like a friend, for example, by using a friendly tone or making small talk.
Recognizing these tactics can help you maintain your composure and remember that they are not your friend.
Sometimes, it might seem harmless to cooperate with the police, especially when you think you didn't commit the crime. Many believe they do not need a criminal defense lawyer while answering questions from police detectives.
However, no matter how cordial they appear, always take these interactions seriously. They are not your best buddy, and their job in these scenarios is not to protect you. Rather, it's to interrogate or arrest you for an alleged crime, and saying one wrong thing could put you at a disadvantage.
If police are questioning you, know your rights and contact our law firm as soon as possible. Our attorneys can represent you during police interrogations, ensuring that your rights are protected and helping you answer your questions legally and effectively.
A criminal defense lawyer can advise you on what to say, what not to say, and when to invoke your right to remain silent or request an attorney, empowering you to navigate police questioning with confidence.
First and Foremost, Know Your Rights
Every individual has certain rights under the U.S. Constitution, including during police interrogations. Most notably, the Fifth Amendment protects your right to remain silent to avoid self-incrimination, and the Sixth Amendment ensures your right to legal counsel.
Additionally, the Miranda warning, commonly beginning with "You have the right to remain silent," is required to be given before a custodial interrogation. If these rights are not properly stated to you, any incriminating statements may be inadmissible in court.
In other words, remember your Miranda rights. Even if you remain calm and keep your answers brief, you could still face arrest. If officers continue interrogations under custody, remember you have the right to remain silent, speak with an attorney before questioning, and have an attorney present during questioning.
Understanding Police Interrogation Tactics
Police officers in California are trained in interrogation tactics designed to elicit confessions or incriminating statements.
These can range from the "good cop, bad cop" routine to other psychological manipulations, such as faking sympathy or understanding to make you feel more at ease. The police do not care about you or your family, regardless of a seemingly friendly demeanor.
Their primary goal is to obtain any evidence that could incriminate you, regardless of its integrity. Thus, despite their friendliness, these tactics can lead to false confessions or statements that could be misconstrued in court.
Put more simply, police are actively looking for justification to charge you with a crime, and the number one way they obtain that justification is through your answers to their questions.
This is why you need a lawyer present, regardless of your guilt or innocence, and why you should respectfully decline to answer any questions until you have one. Here are some important things to remember:
- Law enforcement officers are not your friends.
- The less information you give the police, the better.
- The best way to reveal the truth is through your attorney.
- Refusing an interview without a lawyer is not a crime.
- Miranda warnings give you the right to stop questioning at any time.
- Police are trained to build a rapport to make you feel comfortable.
Now, let's explore some practical dos and don'ts to help you navigate police questioning.
Dos When Being Interrogated by Police
Do Request an Attorney
Whether you're a suspect or a witness, invoking your right to have a California criminal defense attorney present during questioning is one of the most critical and effective ways to protect yourself. Once you ask for an attorney, the law prohibits officers from continuing the interrogation until your attorney is present. If you're detained for questioning, let this be the first thing you do.
Do Affirm Your Right to Remain Silent
No matter how adamant the police are to obtain answers, you have an absolute right to remain silent. Never feel pressure to say anything that could incriminate you, especially if your attorney is not yet present. Politely inform the officer that you're invoking your right to remain silent.
Do Remain Calm and Polite
Stay composed, regardless of the circumstances. Police officers are trained to observe behavior, and aggressive or hostile behavior can escalate the situation and may lead to additional charges or complications. Treat the officers courteously, even if you feel the questioning is unfair. Remaining calm and courteous not only reflects well on you but also helps you think more clearly under pressure.
Do Ask If You're Free to Leave
If you have not been arrested, you may not be required to stay and answer questions. Politely ask, "Am I free to leave?" If the officer says yes, you may leave. If you're being detained, however, remain respectful and cooperative within the bounds of the law.
Do Pay Attention to What Is Being Asked
Listening carefully to what the officer says can provide important context and prevent misunderstandings. Some questions may seem harmless but are intended to draw out incriminating statements. Be cautious, as your responses could be misinterpreted later.
Do Document Everything Afterward
After an encounter with law enforcement, write down all the details you remember, such as names of officers, times, locations, and what was said. This record may become invaluable to your defense attorney as your case progresses.
Don'ts When Being Interrogated by Police
Don't Volunteer Additional Information
One of the most common mistakes people make is oversharing. When answering police questions, keep your responses concise and direct. Avoid elaboration or offering information beyond what's specifically asked. Even a seemingly innocent comment can provide officers with new angles to explore against you.
Don't Lie to the Police
Lying to the police can have serious legal consequences. Providing false information is a crime under California law, and making untruthful statements will damage your credibility if your case proceeds to court. If you don't wish to answer, invoke your right to remain silent instead.
Don't Guess or Speculate
If you choose to answer a question, never speculate or guess. If you don't know the answer, simply say, "I don't know." Speculating can lead to inconsistent statements that may be used against you.
Don't Give Consent to Searches Without Legal Counsel
If officers ask to search your home, car, or belongings, you have the right to refuse. Do not give verbal or written consent without first consulting with an attorney. Even if you believe you have nothing to hide, consenting to a search can lead to unintended complications.
Don't Make Decisions Without Legal Counsel
If at any point you're asked to sign documents, consent to testing (e.g., DNA or blood tests), or give any type of statement, consult with your attorney first. Even paperwork that seems routine could have implications that only a legal professional can adequately assess.
Don't Get Intimidated into Waiving Your Rights
Officers may employ various tactics to coerce or pressure you into waiving your right to silence or legal representation. Stay firm. Your rights are non-negotiable, and invoking them is never an admission of guilt.
What is the Importance of Having an Attorney?
A belief that innocence alone will safeguard against the consequences of a police interrogation does not consider the reality of the legal system's complexities. Completely innocent people have found themselves entangled in legal battles due to misinterpreted statements or coerced confessions.
The primary role of a criminal defense lawyer is to defend the guilty and protect the rights of all people, innocent or guilty. Suppose you are detained for a police investigation. In that case, always invoke your legal right to have an attorney present before answering any questions.
As noted above, you have the constitutional right to speak with an attorney and do not have to answer police questions. Thus, the best way to avoid falling into an interrogation trap and giving police evidence to use against you is not to speak to the police without first consulting with an attorney.
Contact our California criminal defense law firm for more information. Eisner Gorin LLP is based in Los Angeles, CA.
Related Content:
If you have one phone call from jail, call us! If you are facing criminal charges,